Did you miss our recent webinar on Student Loan forgiveness for Physicians and APPs? We have a quick summary and access to view the webinar on demand here!

Impact of Recent Legislative Changes on Student Loan Forgiveness, Particularly SAVE and IDR Programs

The student loan forgiveness landscape has been significantly impacted by recent legislative changes, particularly concerning the SAVE (Saving on a Valuable Education) plan and other income-driven repayment (IDR) programs. The SAVE plan, intended as an optimal IDR option for borrowers, has been blocked by a federal court, putting those using SAVE into forbearance. This forbearance does not currently qualify for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF).

This court decision impacts other IDR programs because the Biden administration intended to address any negative consequences from the SAVE plan's blockage through a PSLF buyback program once the IDR Account Adjustment is finalized, likely in the fall of 2024. This program would allow borrowers to make a lump sum payment to cover any period where their payments did not qualify for PSLF due to the SAVE plan situation. The details of the PSLF buyback program are expected later in 2024 or early 2025.

While awaiting the buyback program's details, borrowers should be aware that the pause on federal student loan payments instituted under the CARES Act ended in October 2023. Although a 12-month "on-ramp" period offered some leeway, that period has ended. Borrowers must now decide how to proceed with their loans, understanding that forbearance will likely accrue interest and may not count towards PSLF. Using an IDR plan, particularly if pursuing PSLF, is generally recommended.

Adding to the complexity, borrowers who haven't updated their income information since March 2020, when the payment pause began, will need to recertify their income as early as November 2024 and potentially as late as July 2025. This means payments could increase for those whose incomes have risen, which is typical for PSLF.

Five Income-Driven Repayment Plans for Student Loans

  • Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR): While this plan is rarely recommended due to newer, more borrower-friendly options, it is still technically available.
  • Income-Based Repayment (IBR): This plan, introduced around 15 years ago, remains in common use. Notably, it allows borrowers to potentially reduce their monthly payments by filing their taxes as "married filing separately," effectively isolating their income from their spouse's income when calculating monthly payments.
  • Pay As You Earn (PAYE): This program, implemented around 12 years ago, is only available to borrowers who did not take out federal loans before October 1, 2007. Like IBR, PAYE offers the flexibility of filing taxes as "married filing separately" to potentially lower monthly payments.
  • New IBR: Similar to PAYE in its payment calculation structure, this plan offers less favorable interest benefits and is therefore not generally recommended when PAYE is an option.
  • Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE): Introduced nine years ago, this plan was commonly used, especially by married borrowers, as it always used joint income to calculate monthly payments, regardless of tax filing status. However, REPAYE has been replaced by the SAVE plan for eligible borrowers.

It's important to note that the SAVE plan, designed as the most advantageous IDR option for most borrowers, is currently unavailable due to a court order. This has created some uncertainty and requires borrowers to consider alternative options, potentially including older IDR plans, while awaiting further clarification on the SAVE plan's future and the potential implementation of a PSLF buyback program.

Key Considerations for Refinancing Federal Student Loans

When contemplating refinancing your federal student loans, the sources emphasize the importance of carefully weighing the potential benefits against the lost federal loan benefits.

Potential Benefits of Refinancing:

  • Lower Interest Rates: Refinancing with a private lender could potentially lower your interest rate, leading to lower monthly payments and overall interest paid over the life of the loan. This can be particularly appealing to borrowers with high interest rates on their existing federal loans. However, the sources caution that as of late 2023, interest rates for refinancing have been rising, making it crucial to compare current refinancing offers with your existing federal loan rates.

Lost Federal Loan Benefits:

  • Loan Forgiveness Programs: Refinancing federal loans with a private lender makes them ineligible for federal loan forgiveness programs, such as Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF). The sources highlight that for many borrowers, particularly those in public service professions like healthcare, the potential for loan forgiveness through programs like PSLF outweighs the benefits of a slightly lower interest rate.
  • Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) Plans: Federal IDR plans offer payment relief based on your income and family size, potentially leading to lower monthly payments than a refinanced loan, especially during periods of lower income. These plans can be particularly beneficial during residency or fellowship training, as they can significantly reduce monthly payments. Losing access to IDR plans by refinancing could mean higher monthly payments if your income drops or you experience financial hardship.
  • Federal Protections and Flexibility: Federal loans come with certain protections and flexibility not typically offered by private lenders, such as deferment, forbearance, and potential loan forgiveness options in specific circumstances. Refinancing removes these safety nets, potentially leaving you with fewer options during financial difficulties.

When Refinancing Might Make Sense:

  • High Income and Low Debt: The sources suggest that refinancing may be worth considering if you have a high income, low debt, and do not foresee a need for loan forgiveness programs like PSLF or the lower monthly payments offered through IDR plans.
  • Favorable Interest Rate Environment: Refinancing is more attractive when interest rates in the private market are significantly lower than your existing federal loan rates. However, it is crucial to note that interest rate environments can change, as evidenced by the rising refinancing rates mentioned in the sources in late 2023.

Before Refinancing, Consider:

  • Exhaustively Research Federal Benefits: Before refinancing, carefully research and fully understand the federal loan benefits you would be forfeiting, ensuring you are comfortable with the trade-offs.
  • Seek Personalized Advice: Consider consulting a qualified financial advisor or student loan expert to help you evaluate your individual circumstances and make the most informed decision. The sources mention a service, Ben Elevate, that provides personalized assessments and advice regarding student loan repayment strategies. However, this information is provided within the context of the sources and might require independent verification.